The Night Television Tried to Destroy Elvis Presley: One Humiliating Performance, 31 Recordings, and an Unforgettable Comeback!
July 1, 1956. New York City.
Elvis Presley stepped onto a national television stage wearing something almost nobody expected to see on the young rock ’n’ roll sensation: formal evening clothes, a bow tie, and tails.
Behind him stood elegant Greek columns and theatrical curtains. Everything looked like a sophisticated concert hall.
But beside his microphone sat something extraordinary.
A real basset hound, dressed in a tiny top hat and bow tie.
And Elvis Presley, the young man whose electrifying performances had sent America into a frenzy, had been instructed to stand almost perfectly still and sing “Hound Dog” directly to the animal.
The audience laughed.
The television executives got their spectacle.
But behind that carefully staged comedy was a battle over something much bigger than a song.
It was a battle over who Elvis Presley was allowed to be.
Just four weeks earlier, on June 5, 1956, Elvis had appeared on The Milton Berle Show and delivered a performance that sent shockwaves through American television.
Without his guitar, Elvis moved freely to the rhythm of “Hound Dog,” turning the stage into a demonstration of the energy that was transforming popular music.
Millions watched.
Some were thrilled.
Others were outraged.
Newspaper critics attacked his singing, his movements, and his influence on young audiences. Religious and cultural conservatives questioned whether someone like Elvis belonged on family television.
Suddenly, the 21-year-old singer from Memphis had become one of America’s most controversial entertainers.
And Steve Allen, whose Sunday-night television program competed directly with Ed Sullivan, saw an opportunity.
Rather than cancel Elvis’s scheduled appearance, Allen decided to present him in an entirely different setting.
No rebellious movements.
No provocative performance.
No wild rock ’n’ roll atmosphere.
Instead, Elvis would be transformed into a polite, formally dressed entertainer singing to a dog.
The contrast was supposed to be funny.
But for Elvis, the experience was far more complicated.
Photographer Alfred Wertheimer, who documented Elvis during this remarkable period, witnessed the rehearsals and the unusual preparations.
The elaborate set was ready. The dog was dressed. The cameras were waiting.
Yet the animal seemed completely uninterested in its famous singing partner.
At one point, Elvis reportedly slipped away from the theater and was later found playing pinball at a nearby arcade.
He was uncomfortable with the restrictions placed on his performance.
Still, when the cameras rolled, Elvis did what was expected.
He sang.
He stood nearly motionless.
And he performed “Hound Dog” to a basset hound in front of millions of viewers.
Steve Allen had successfully turned the most explosive young performer in America into a television comedy routine.
The ratings suggested a victory.
Allen’s program defeated Ed Sullivan’s show that night.
But winning the ratings battle was not the same as winning the larger cultural war.
Some critics who had previously condemned Elvis now complained that his performance was too restrained.
Others viewed the entire presentation as an attempt to ridicule him.
Writer John Lardner, defending Elvis in Newsweek, argued that the singer had essentially been set up by the television production.
Years later, Priscilla Presley described the experience as humiliating for Elvis.
But the most remarkable part of the story was still ahead.
Because less than 24 hours later, Elvis Presley walked into an RCA recording studio in New York City — and everything changed.
On July 2, 1956, Elvis gathered with guitarist Scotty Moore, bassist Bill Black, drummer D. J. Fontana, and the Jordanaires.
This time, there were no Greek columns.
No ridiculous costume.
No dog waiting beside the microphone.
And no television producer demanding that Elvis suppress the movements and musical instincts that had made him famous.
There was only the music.
They began recording “Hound Dog.”
Once.
Twice.
Again.
And again.
Elvis was not satisfied.
He wanted the performance to have the energy, aggression, and excitement that he believed the song demanded.
The band kept playing.
The studio filled with pounding rhythms, sharp guitar breaks, and Elvis’s unmistakable voice.
By the time the recording was finished, they had worked through 31 takes.
Take 28 became the master recording.
And that recording would help define an entire era.
The contrast was extraordinary.
One night, Elvis had been standing stiffly on television, singing to an animal as part of a comedy sketch.
The next afternoon, he was creating one of the most recognizable recordings in rock ’n’ roll history.
Whether the intensity of that session was directly inspired by his frustration with Steve Allen remains a matter of interpretation.
But the timing was unforgettable.
And Elvis was not finished.
During the same recording session, he also recorded “Don’t Be Cruel,” another song destined to become a massive hit.
On July 4, Elvis returned to Memphis for a performance at Russwood Park.
There, in front of his own audience, he made his position clear.
“Those people in New York are not going to change me none.”
It was a declaration that captured the spirit of the young performer.
He would not abandon the energy that had brought him from Memphis to national fame.
He would not allow hostile critics to decide what rock ’n’ roll should sound like.
And he would not remain the restrained entertainer Steve Allen had presented to America.
On July 13, RCA released “Hound Dog” and “Don’t Be Cruel” together on a single.
The result was extraordinary.
The record climbed to No. 1 on the Billboard pop chart and remained there for 11 weeks.
It also achieved enormous success on the country and rhythm-and-blues charts.
The two songs became defining hits of Elvis’s career.
And the irony was impossible to ignore.
The song television had turned into a joke had become one of the biggest records in America.
Steve Allen had won one Sunday-night ratings battle.
But Elvis Presley had won something far more enduring.
His fame exploded.
Ed Sullivan, whose program had lost to Allen’s Elvis appearance, soon secured the young singer for a series of appearances reportedly worth $50,000.
On September 9, 1956, Elvis made his first appearance on The Ed Sullivan Show.
Millions tuned in.
The phenomenon that critics had tried to contain was now impossible to ignore.
Elvis would never return to Steve Allen’s program.
And as the years passed, even Allen came to acknowledge that the young singer possessed remarkable staying power.
Today, the image of Elvis singing to a basset hound remains one of the strangest moments in early rock ’n’ roll television history.
But the recording made the following afternoon continues to represent something much more powerful.
The voice.
The rhythm.
The attitude.
The unmistakable sound of a young artist changing American music.
Nearly seven decades later, people still listen to “Hound Dog.”
They still recognize that explosive opening.
They still hear the confidence of a performer who refused to disappear beneath the criticism.
And perhaps that is the most remarkable irony of all.
On July 1, 1956, television tried to make Elvis Presley look harmless.
On July 2, he recorded a song that helped make him immortal.
They could dress him in tails. They could tell him to stand still. They could even make him sing to a dog.
But they could never take the rock ’n’ roll out of Elvis Presley.
And that is why, after all these years, the world still remembers the King.
What do you think? Was Steve Allen simply creating television comedy, or did he deliberately humiliate Elvis Presley? And was Elvis’s legendary recording of “Hound Dog” the ultimate answer to his critics?